Dissertation > Excellent graduate degree dissertation topics show

Research Methods referee judicial officials in Song

Author: SunYing
Tutor: DongChangChun
School: Nanjing Normal University
Course: Legal History
Keywords: the judgment methods proof proof-test legal pragmatism common sense
CLC: D926
Type: Master's thesis
Year: 2011
Downloads: 83
Quote: 0
Read: Download Dissertation

Abstract


In contemporary juridical practice, the methods of judicial judgment are the methods in which a judge constructs a case as the minor premise of a trial and that as the major premise of a trial, and finally make a logical judgment. Obviously, the decision method is more of a vertical concept than a horizontal one. In the narrow sense, the methods of judgment include the methods of confirming a fact, the methods of seeking laws and the methods of legal inference.In this article, the author sets in ancient China’s Song Dynasty, when the feudal society was highly developed. A series of concrete cases have been put up to expound in detail the methods and techniques adopted by judicial officials of Song Dynasty in confirming facts and seeking laws, such as how to discriminate and utilize proofs, how to do proof-test, how to seek for laws, and how to employ "extrajudicial mercy", etc. Because the inference is perfoliate in the process of judgment, this article doesn’t list independently, but describes the way of ADR in our country. The first step is to analyze the theory basic, people’s consciousness of don’t like sue to the government is the thought basic, the exist of clan and the limit of lawsuit are the immediate qualification; the second step is to give same examples to get an intuitive mastery.Great importance was attached to the third part of the article, in which an in-depth summary was made of the features of the judicial judgment methods used by officials of Song Dynasty. The author maintains that the utility of deciding concepts and diversity of methods account for the fact that the judicial decision methods of Song Dynasty have yielded unusually brilliant results. Therefore, detailed expounding has been made on each respectively, arriving at a conclusion that traditional Chinese aspects of law are of great significance to deciding methods. The connection among justice, law and favor would directly affect the application of deciding methods to some extent, people’s consciousness of do not like sue to the government influence the judges of Song Dynasty; in the process of judgment, pluralistic ways of judicial show that the judge will use the law to make decisions for one hand and use something else to judge for the other hand, such as common sense. The author has made a comparison between the traditional Chinese deciding methods and contemporary ones, obtaining that the key distinctions between the two lie in two aspects:difference in judgment concepts; difference in method normalization. In the end, after ejecting the dross and assimilating the essence, the author deems that undoubtedly faults can be found in the judgment methods of Song Dynasty, yet there is every reason that they are worth our deliberation and reference. The ultimate purpose of this article is to draw the parts that shall be positive toward contemporary judicial reform, hence advancing improvement in the judgment methods.

Related Dissertations

  1. Study on System of Electronic Documetnt Security Signature,TN918.2
  2. Research on Readjustment Evaluation and Proof Method of Tianjin Ancient Coast and Wetland National Nature Reserve,S759.9
  3. Altitude parabolic tort liability study,D923
  4. The Research on Issues on Identifying Environmental Tort Causations,D923
  5. Research on the Allocation System of "No Legal Basis" Burden of Proof in Unjust Enrichment,D913
  6. A Research on the Claim Rights for Lessee’s Accessio Interests,D923
  7. On the Evidence of the Referee in the Principles of the Criminal Procedure Law,D925.2
  8. Public recognition of Criminal Justice,D925.2
  9. On the Improvement of Proof Invalidity System,D925.1
  10. The Concept of Law and Method of Realization of Law,D90
  11. The Common Sense of Criminal Justice,D924
  12. The Modeling and Simulation of Explosion-proof Truck,TD52
  13. The Research on the Burden of Proof in Patent Litigation,D923.42
  14. On the Causation of Tort Law,D923
  15. Mine explosion Diesel Intake System Simulation and Optimization,TK42
  16. The Research of Complaint for Divorce Damages,D923.9
  17. Crime of stock market manipulation,D924.3
  18. Antitrust Study of Judicial Remedy,D922.294
  19. The Research on Proved Sentencing Facts,D925.2
  20. Rules of judicial,D916
  21. Studies on the Burden of Proof about the Procedural Facts in Criminal Procedure,D925.2

CLC: > Political, legal > Legal > Chinese law > Justice system
© 2012 www.DissertationTopic.Net  Mobile